
Victoria Gomelsky and Rob Bates kick off their chat looking forward to Victoria’s upcoming trip to Akoya pearl farms in Japan, but they quickly get to the main event: the jewelry looks Victoria sees trending for the holidays. Rob forecasts how holiday business will treat the industry this year and gives some updates and background on the pending De Beers sale. The sale of Mervis Diamond Importers to Solomon Brothers prompts a broader conversation about the issue of succession in family-owned jewelry businesses. The hosts share their thoughts on F. P. Journe, and how the brand has masterfully managed its scarcity, fanning the flames of passionate Journe enthusiasts all the while.
Listen Now
Title sponsor: De Beers (adiamondisforever.com)
Show Notes
01:00 Victoria’s trip to visit Akoya pearl farms in Japan
03:40 Her experience judging the AGTA Spectrum Awards
06:00 Holiday gift trend: charming charms
07:15 Trending: silver and alternate metals
09:30 Trending: beads
10:40 Holiday business forecasting
13:00 De Beers sale updates
16:10 Solomon Brothers, Mervis Diamond Importers, and succession
20:40 F.P. Journe, a masterclass in managing scarcity
Episode Credits
Hosts: Rob Bates and Victoria Gomelsky
Producer and engineer: Natalie Chomet
Editor: Riley McCaskill
Plugs: @jckmagazine; adiamondisforever.com
Episode Transcript
This transcript has been abridged and edited for clarity.
Victoria:
Hey everyone, welcome to The Jewelry District… How’s it going, Rob?
Rob:
It’s going all right.
Victoria:
I’m leaving for Japan on Monday. So, I’ll be there for the first chunk of November.
Rob:
What are you what are you doing there exactly?
Victoria:
I am going with the Pearl Association of America and the Japanese Pearl Exporters Association to visit a number of family-owned Akoya pearl farms off the coast of Kobe.
I’m really excited. My very first press trip— in jewelry or any business for that matter—was a trip to the pearl farms of Australia, Paspaley Farm, way back in the year 2000 when I went to see how they culture Australian pearls in Port Bremer, which is on the very tip of the top end of Australia.
So it feels full circle. I’ll have a lot to say about it when I come back about Akoya pearls and what’s new from Japan.
We’ll go into the actual pearl farms correct to meet the farmers. These are smaller family-owned farms, so a different perspective than the more industrial operations.
I don’t know much about the business landscape of the pearl industry in Japan, so we’ll also be going to the Japan Pearl Exporters Association Fair.
I expect to be utterly inundated with pearl information—at least about the Japanese side of the industry, which of course is the original cultured pearl industry of the world.
Rob:
And you just came back from Dallas for the AGTA Spectrum Awards, right?
Victoria:
Yes, I was honored to be an invited editor. There were a number of editors there, including our very own Amy Elliott who’s been working with AGTA to help promote the Spectrum and Cutting Edge Awards.
This is their annual colored stone competition. Spectrum judges the finished jewelry and then Cutting Edge is the lapidary work of the cutting of the loose stones and various suites of stones.
There’s no exaggeration—I was blown away by the utter caliber of these pieces. They were so inventive. Some of the stones I’d didn’t know about: gems like axinite, which is a phenomenal gem that I have literally never heard of.
And I’m somebody who has been covering gems since 2001—my very first Tucson shows. I’ve made it a point to understand what I can about these stones. I’m not a gemologist, but I really am a student of the marketplace and it was exciting.
I genuinely loved the experience. Our job was simply to choose an editor’s award favorite for Spectrum and an editor’s award winner for Cutting Edge. And I can’t tell you how difficult that was.
I really don’t envy the judges who were there in the days leading up to when we arrived because they had to determine all the winners—you know, the first, second, third honorable mentions in different categories. Stuller this year had a new category dedicated to its color of the year.
For 2026, it was signature red, so lots of beautiful red jewels and gems. It was fun. I hope to do it again. It was just a wonderful weekend, and it really got me excited about color, not that I needed to. I’ve always been excited about color. It is certainly my favorite portion of this world we cover.
But as a segue into what will be on many of our listeners’ minds, of course we’re in the thick of the holiday season.
Rob:
Yeah, we’re getting there.
Victoria:
When people are listening to this, we’re in November and Thanksgiving’s around the corner. Lots of people are trying to make sure they know what they should be promoting.
I can’t speak enough for color because there’s such a wide range of price point possibilities.
I have a piece running in a gift section of the New York Times about jewelry and how, people were spending let’s say $2,500 and under for a gift of jewelry. And in the era of $4,000-plus gold, that has changed what can you afford for $2,500 quite a bit. Often, it’s not much.
So, what we’re seeing in the world of 14k and 18k gold is a lot of charms—diamond and gold charms. They’re small but they’re charming—bah-dum-bump! They still have that enduring value, so I think we’re seeing a lot of retailers, designers, and manufacturers lean on charms. I’ve never seen so many charms in my life—and not just for bracelets, but charms that you can attach to a chain or a leather cord and put around your neck. That is one utterly ubiquitous item this this holiday.
We’re also seeing a lot of people start to embrace silver. It’s been a slow transition. I think a lot of designers really committed to yellow gold over the last five, 10 years, and some designers won’t ever go into silver. They are committed 18k yellow people, but there are those who want to be able to offer an opening price point.
For example, a jeweler named Katkim based in Manhattan Beach here in Southern California just introduced earlier in October her first silver collection with price points starting at $420. You know, that is not a price point you could get in karat yellow gold. Apart from some manufacturers like a Royal Chain who really specialize in gold and know how to lighten the material so they can hit a price point.
For that matter, when I saw Royal Chain at the JIS show in Miami, they had a couple of great collections, one was Luchita, which is 18k gold with silver. It was very affordable but still had quite a lot of yellow in it so it felt valuable. Another collection was of stretch bracelets that felt thin but still gold, which were also very affordable.
If you’re a manufacturer with that kind of know-how to make a substantial-seeming gold piece that isn’t weighty then you can sell that gold for a reasonable price point. But for the most part, people are having to embrace all kinds of other materials.
I also mentioned in this New York Times story: A jeweler that I’d known for a while has a new sibling brand called Tacit Fine Jewelry, which I was introduced to at the Luxury show back in June. It was part of the NouvelleBox showroom. It’s ceramic coated silver in these fun, colorful styles that are inspired by Mylar balloons. The metallic quality of the ceramic that coats this silver gives it that balloon-like feel.
They’re really fun pieces—great gifts. Everything’s designed to be in the $1,000 to $3,000 range, so as the holiday approaches and you’re leaning on your gifting case, you’ll want to consider some small items in gold or alternative materials.
One final trend that I want to emphasize, which links back to our color conversation, is beads. You can do a lot of big looks with colored stone beads, and they don’t have to be expensive.
You can do green onyx that’s been faceted in these cool barrel shapes; you can do regular onyx; you could do higher-end material—but beads allow you to get that big look. I’m seeing lots of color 14k gold clasps so it still feels like there’s some value there and some preciousness, but they don’t have to be super expensive. So I’d say lean on beads.
Western wear of course is still strong. It’s been the 250th anniversary of our country and a lot of Americana has emerged this year. It’s the year of the horse. But I think it’s a new staple versus a trend, this idea of anything with a Western motif—be it a cowboy hat, cowboy boots, a lasso motif, or horses. Anything with equestrian themes are perennials at this point. All those things are solid bets for the holiday.
Rob:
I’d like to talk a little bit about holiday trends. Obviously, I don’t cover the fashion like you do but tell me if you agree with this:
It’s been a strong year for jewelry, and definitely at the high end. You look at these conglomerates—jewelry is killing it to an unusual extent.
I’ve asked a lot of people why, and I’ve heard the standard, “People give jewelry for emotional reasons. They like something unique.” It’s true and I believe it, but people can’t point to why at this particular time jewelry is having this last-minute renaissance. It’s not as strong as the Covid days, which were really just amazing, but I think a lot of independent jewelers are doing very well.
As I mentioned, jewelry is doing very well at the conglomerates—Kering, LVMH, Richemont, and most of the independents seem to be holding up. There’s generally that K-shaped trend where people buy fewer units, but they pay more for them.
That seems to be the case for natural diamonds and colored stones. The only exception to that is lab-grown diamonds, which are selling more because they are a less expensive item.
But in general, I’m hearing that people are hanging in, but with the trend of fewer units and bigger dollars. So, you’re not seeing as many customers, but the ones you do see have money and want to spend.
This is not a great economy given the gas prices and all the things we’re hearing about tariffs and everything else, but maybe it is because these are fraught times, or people feel emotionally on edge, but jewelry seems to be doing well and jewelry does seem to do well during fraught times.
A lot of independents are having a strong year and they’re hopeful for a strong holiday. They’re hopeful that it’s going to keep up.
Sponsor message:
What proves natural diamonds are rare? Desert diamonds. Because just like the people we love, no two Desert diamonds are alike. They shine in sunlit whites, golden-hour champagnes, sunrise blushes…colors that are unique, special…rare. Just like the people they’re meant for. This holiday, introduce your clients to natural Desert diamonds, now in iconic pieces. A Diamond Is Forever. Visit ADiamondIsForever.com to learn more.
Rob:
I hinted at the names on the last podcast and I probably should have been a little bolder because it ended up on Reuters and Bloomberg, but this consortium wants to buy De Beers. It’s headed by former CEO Gareth Penny, and Signet and Richemont are probably going to play some role—probably not a big role, but they’ll probably be there as members of the consortium, maybe to have some exposure and to support the natural diamond industry in general.
So that should be interesting. I have no idea how it’s going to work. Over the last week or so I’ve gotten two different calls from due-diligence firms asking me about three separate sightholders who are supposed to be in this consortium: Grandview Klein, Pluczenik, and Diarough. So, perhaps that’s a sign that this this sale is finally getting going.
I thought that was interesting because I usually don’t get those calls. Signet and Richemont, you don’t necessarily need to do due diligence to a huge extent, but that’s something that’s going on. Hopefully this saga, which has dragged on way longer than I think any of us wanted, will get settled.
Victoria:
Yes, it has been a long time. I mean, I thought we were going to hear around JCK time.
Rob:
Yeah, at one point Al Cook said it’s a matter of weeks and unfortunately it didn’t turn out that way.
We do hear that one sticking point for the deal was that some of the private investors—especially some of the people who are putting up the money—did not want majority control for the governments.
There are three governments that are reportedly supposed to be involved in this deal: Namibia, Botswana, and Angola. Botswana already owns 15% of De Beers and from what they’re saying, the deal will work out so that between the three of these governments, they will get less than 50% of De Beers.
So, if that’s settled—and that seemed like a big sticking point because when you deal with governments it’s always a big hassle—that would certainly be progress.
Victoria:
Wow, yeah. I’m so glad you’re following this, Rob, because there are so many twists and turns and developments and delays, it’s really hard to keep straight.
Victoria:
Well, is there was there anything else brewing?
Rob:
Yeah, there was an interesting sale that happened. It’s very fresh in my mind because I just got off the phone with Jaron Solomon who’s the head of Solomon Brothers. It’s a well-regarded three-store chain in the Atlanta area. He just made a deal to purchase Mervis Diamond Importers, which is another well-regarded three-store chain in what it’s called the DMV: the DC, Maryland, Virginia area.
When I talked to Jaron, he said there’s obviously a problem with succession in this industry right because somebody like Zed and Ronnie Mervis, who owned Mervis Diamond importers, didn’t have another generation to hand the business down to.
And yet they had a great name in the local area. They’d spend millions and millions of dollars on radio advertising, so they had huge brand and store awareness.
So what do you do? You could go out of business. You could run a going out of business sale, but that’s not great for your employees. After all that time spent building up a business, you don’t necessarily want to just say, “I’m calling it quits,” and that’s the end.
So Mervis ended up selling to Solomon Brothers. One of the things Jaron Solomon said to me was, it really put this on his radar just how many good, well-known businesses are out there that he’d be interested in possibly acquiring at some point. He’ll see how it works with Mervis, but he grew to respect the legacy that these companies represent.
Something’s been in an area for so long, it has such great awareness, and people’s children and parents and grandchildren all bought there. You don’t necessarily want to throw that all away.
You hear a lot about private equity buying local businesses like doctor and dentist practices especially. A lot of doctors are being bought out by PE, which is not great, but they don’t want jewelers necessarily because jewelers usually have heavy inventory and slow turn and it’s not a business that they understand.
You could have let’s say an $8 million dollar a year business or $10 million business. Those are substantial businesses, but not necessarily as attractive to PE as something that has lower expenses, like plumbers. Apparently, PE is buying out local plumbers.
So again, you have all these great jewelers. I used to do this roundup of all the stores who had closed the prior year. And one of the things you heard a lot was jewelers saying, “My business is great. I just had my best year ever, but I’m near retirement age and I can’t do it anymore.”
I think that’s a very common thing in this industry. If Jaron Solomon is going to be the one who starts looking at some of those businesses, that’s great.
I think there needs to be a good exit strategy for some of these great businesses besides just going out of business and selling your inventory for pennies on the dollar. There’s nothing wrong with that. Many people choose to do it. It’s definitely a dilemma for a lot of people in this business.
Victoria:
I feel like I’ve been talking about this idea of consolidation since I entered the jewelry industry 25 years ago.
It’s a really fragmented industry. There are a lot of independents out there and it’s unlike other industries that have consolidated long ago. It is a testament to the families and the enduring relationships that there are still so many independently owned businesses in this industry.
Every family, every business has to do what makes sense for that business. But when I meet a jeweler and they say their kids aren’t interested, I’m always a little heartbroken for them.
Rob:
Yeah, you feel bad, right?
Victoria:
even though I understand it’s a hard business: It’s up and downs, but yes, always a little heartbroken.
Rob:
Speaking of independents, I read a very compelling piece in the New York Times about F.P. Journe.
Victoria:
Well, thank you. I’ll go back to June, when out of the blue I get an email from Phillips, the very well-known auctioneer that is slaying—as the kids like to say—the watch business these days in the secondary market.
They have a very close relationship with a lot of F. P. Journe collectors, and one of them is Kevin O’Leary. Kevin O’Leary, many people will know as the celebrity investor co-host of Shark Tank. An outsized personality, but very committed to watches, a very intense watch enthusiast. He’s Canadian and he and his wife Linda have been hosting collector friends at their lake house in the Muskoka region, which is about two hours north of Toronto—a really fancy moneyed region. It was the setting for Heated Rivalry’s cottage scenes. They call it the Hamptons of Toronto.
They invited me to join this gathering that had been building over the course of a few years. The gathering included F. P. Journe’s North America general manager, Pierre Halimi, well-known to anybody who’s ever think thought about getting Journe.
They invited me, so I paid my own way and met all these very high-end collectors who were all linked by their love and dare I say obsession with François-Paul Journe, the Geneva watchmaker founded the brand F. P. Journe in 1999.
For many years, Journe was an extreme talent, a devoted specialist in chronometry making ultra precise watches, but only in the last few years and especially since the pandemic—maybe 2018 or so was a turning point—his watches are the hottest things in the market. In some cases, they sell for 10 times their retail value.
In fact, those flippers have been traumatizing to the brand. So, the brand has one of the strictest allocation policies you’ll ever encounter.
When I was at JIS, I visited the F. P. Journe boutique in Miami and wasn’t allowed to take any pictures. I didn’t feel comfortable even taking notes, but the point is, you can barely walk into that store without having a reason to be there and you have to be vetted.
That brand is not interested in selling to anybody who isn’t going to be a collector of their brand and love and cherish that piece. If for some reason years down the line, you do need to sell your F. P. Journe that you acquired on the primary market or were allocated, then you need to go to that brand and talk to them about it, because if you end up just selling it somewhere and making a bundle, you are most certainly going to be blacklisted.
It is a brand that has really managed to keep its scarcity in line, keep that exclusivity, really develop a cult—I don’t use that word lightly—of obsessive followers. They have a club called the F. P. Journe Society. It’s not associated or in any way run by the brand. It is a global collection of people that you have to be invited to join. They just commune on their love of Journe and span all kinds of nationalities and industries, but right now, all those newly minted AI gazillionaires will most likely be coming for Journe if they haven’t already and they’re going to have a hard time getting them.
It’s a masterclass in how to manage scarcity and rarity.
Rob:
Here’s a question: How do they scout people? If somebody sells their Journe, how do they know you’ve done a bad thing and you’re off the list? How do they check people out when they come into the boutique? It’s hard to imagine a simple and easy and way to do that.
Victoria:
How they know is, they have serial numbers. Every piece has a way of identifying it so it is tied to the original point of sale.
Rob:
It’s like big watchmaker is watching you.
Victoria:
Well kind of, but when you sell somebody something for $30,000 and they turn around and flip it for $200,000, $300,000, in some cases over $1 million—I mean, his pieces have earned millions at auction at Phillips for that matter—it cheapens the brand in a way.
It’s amazing that people want it that much, but it becomes this flex, which is the note my article ends on.
In terms of how they vet people, you have to put your name on a wish list. It’s not a waiting list, it’s a wish list, and you befriend a sales advisor, and over time you prove to them that you know what you’re talking about.
One of the most interesting things is that this is a brand that really insists you know what you’re buying, because when somebody asks you, “What is that?” You can’t just be like, “Oh, isn’t it pretty? It’s cool. I spent a bundle. It’s going to make me a bundle.” That’s exactly the opposite of what they’re looking for.
They want you to know exactly what distinguishes F. P. Journe as a watchmaker, as a chronometrist, and they have their ways. It’s a long story, but anybody who’s interested, I’m happy to talk Journe. It is a fascinating case study of demand, supply, and hype.
Any views expressed in this podcast do not reflect the opinion of JCK, its management, or its advertisers.
- Subscribe to the JCK News Daily
- Subscribe to the JCK Special Report
- Follow JCK on Instagram: @jckmagazine
- Follow JCK on X: @jckmagazine
- Follow JCK on Facebook: @jckmagazine


