
Margot McKinney’s first New York City boutique celebrates her Australian heritage, showcases her impressive jewelry lineage, and beautifully embraces the location’s architecture.
The two-floor flagship at 781 Fifth Avenue sits at the corner of Fifth Avenue and East 59th Street, inside the historic Sherry-Netherland building across from Central Park’s Grand Army Plaza. This is McKinney’s third store; her others are in The Peninsula Beverly Hills and Brisbane.
The high jeweler says she wanted the space to help build and enrich the relationships she has built within jewelry and with her clients.
“For me, jewelry has always been about people and relationships. My family has been in the jewelry business for five generations, and one of the most important things I have learnt is that the most wonderful relationships begin with the conversation,” McKinney tells JCK.

“I never wanted our boutique to feel like a conventional jewelry store. I wanted it to feel more like a beautiful private residence, where guests are welcomed, feel comfortable, enjoy themselves, and perhaps stay rather longer than they intended,” she says.
The fun part was blending her Australian design aesthetic with New York City’s character. Having an architecturally fascinating space was the starting point—the boutique’s exterior has a rare 1984 façade designed by Michael Graves & Associates, which the firm created for Diane von Furstenberg.
“I felt it was very important that our interiors should respect and complement the character and elegance of this extraordinary address. At the same time, I wanted to bring something distinctly Australian to Fifth Avenue,” McKinney says. “There is a wonderful sense of optimism, individuality, and freedom in Australian design, and I think that sits beautifully alongside New York’s sophistication and energy.”
McKinney worked with Tom Postma Design to create a private salon centering on conversation and discovery. It begins with McKinney’s signature color, Kelly green, which is featured on the entrance and rises through the staircase.

“Green has become very much a part of my identity and the Margot McKinney world. I have always loved color, and it is at the very heart of my jewelry designs. I work with some of the most extraordinary colored gemstones that nature has created, so it seems only natural that the spaces in which we present them should celebrate color too.
“Our signature green is confident, joyful, and welcoming,” she says. “It makes a statement, certainly, but it also has a wonderful warmth. I wanted our Fifth Avenue boutique to be immediately recognizable as Margot McKinney, with a personality all of its own. I think the green achieves that beautifully.”
McKinney and Postma moved the space’s staircase to open up the area and make the mezzanine a key part of the boutique. Its balustrade and handrail replicate the look of ironwork found in McKinney’s great-grandfather’s building, which held the family’s jewelry store and their home.
The first-floor walls are a medium blue and the ceiling is a Wedgwood blue, a favorite of McKinney’s mother. Another special feature is the wallpaper, which is hand-embroidered. Velvet drapes highlight the store’s tall ceilings.

The furnishings are meant to surprise and delight as well. There is a secret, second-floor bar that is fully stocked and ready for McKinney to pour a cocktail for clients as they talk jewelry. McKinney worked closely with her friend, Christopher Hyland, to select seating, such as the handcrafted Spanish chaise that dates from the 1950s.
McKinney also thoughtfully displays her high jewelry throughout the space. The store features six of her masterpieces, including the Aurora Collier, Galaxy Collier, Mirage Collier, and the Lillian Collier. Her work is known for its use of color, texture, and scale as well as connection to Australian opals and South Sea pearls.
“There are extraordinary stories behind every one of my jewels, from the remarkable gemstones and Australian South Sea pearls to the people who have helped bring each creation to life. I love sharing those stories, and equally, I love hearing the stories of the people who visit us,” she says.
“The jewelry is, of course, the reason people come through the door, but it is the relationships we create that make the experience so special.”
Top: Margot McKinney opened her third boutique in November in New York City inside a historic icon. (Photos courtesy of Margot McKinney)
- Subscribe to the JCK News Daily
- Subscribe to the JCK Special Report
- Follow JCK on Instagram: @jckmagazine
- Follow JCK on X: @jckmagazine
- Follow JCK on Facebook: @jckmagazine



