Amazon’s Demi-Fine Jewelry Offerings Are Improving

Amazon isn’t a major player in fine jewelry, and we don’t see it stocking Irene Neuwirth and David Webb—or even more affordable sought-after brands such as Mejuri or AUrate—anytime soon.

But its digital aisles are very much bulging with demi-fine and non-fine jewelry. Type the phrase “14k jewelry” into Amazon’s search bar, and a cornucopia of 14k gold pieces, mainly gold-plated styles, pop up from global manufacturers including Miabella, Pori Jewelers, and Lifetime Jewelry (along with low-cost jewelry retailer Ross-Simons).

Prices are rock-bottom, as expected. A pair of real cultured pearl earrings in a 14k gold setting go for $59 (and are “Prime,” so delivered within two days for members). Genuine 14k yellow gold continuous hoops from Art and Molly start at $24.99 for the 10 mm size.

Pavoi rose gold ring
Pavoi 14k rose gold–plated CZ ring, $13.95

Some of the trendiest jewelry styles being sold by the world’s  biggest retailer—which was valued at $702 billion in January 2019—are sold under a brand called Pavoi, which looks like an Amazon-owned brand, because its website has zero contact and bio info, and its link on Instagram goes directly to an Amazon product page. [Update: An anonymous commenter on this story informed us Pavoi is not an Amazon house brand, but only a name a manufacturer gave the collection that’s made exclusively for Amazon; a request for the identity of the manufacturer has not yet been returned]. 

“On trend, high quality, always attainable” is Pavoi’s tagline on the site, and in searches for trendier, lightweight styles—such as stacking rings, huggie hoops, and X rings—the brand always shows up.

I ordered a few Pavoi pieces, including 14k gold–plated huggie earrings with CZ ($13.95) and was impressed by their solid, non-flimsy quality and fine-jewelry look. I ordered the huggies to stand in for a $330 14k white gold and diamond pair I’d purchased last year, but had lost one.

One of the earrings below is Amazon’s Pavoi 14k gold-plated huggie (again, priced at $13.95), and the other is a solid 14k white gold-with-diamonds hoop valued at more than $150. Can you tell which is which? To most naked eyes, the differences in the patina of the metals, which is how I can tell them apart, would be all but imperceptible. The mismatched pair can easily be worn together.

Pavoi earring
The Amazon Pavoi earring is on the right (photo by Emili Vesilind)

With Pavoi, Amazon is clearly trying to capture the starter fine jewelry buyer. How can brick-and-mortar stores compete? By carrying a wide variety of trendy, affordable jewelry—from fine to demi-fine to costume pieces. Give that 17-year-old with multiple ear piercings a range of studs and mini hoops to play with and buy. And make sure they’re priced to move. She’s chasing a look, not an heirloom.

Top: CZ and 14k gold-plated Pavoi ear crawlers, $12.95 (all jewelry photos courtesy of Amazon)

Follow me on Instagram: @emilivesilind

Follow JCK on Instagram: @jckmagazine
Follow JCK on Twitter: @jckmagazine
Follow JCK on Facebook: @jckmagazine

JCK Magazine Editor