When Jewelers Bash Each Other - Cutting Remarks

JCK Online

Cutting Remarks

Blog

Cutting Remarks

« LVMH and Tiffany (Speculation ... | Main | Diamond Shavings: Your Friday ... »

Link This | Email this | Blog This | Comments (4)

Rob Bates

When Jewelers Bash Each Other
February 29, 2008

We know jewelers like to badmouth the competition. I'd heard it was possible to get sued over, but never heard of an actual case until this one.

Here's the sequence of events:

- Roger Clemens was going to buy a $750,000 (oval, purplish-pink, 2.5-carat) ring from Michael Ansen.

- Clemens talks to dealer Charles Krypell, who says Ansen is "gouging" him.

- Clemens cancels the sale, buys from Krypell.

- Ansen sues Krypell for $5.1 million for defamation. ($5 million, for not even a million dollar sale?! You gotta love lawyers!)

Now, a court will have to decide who's telling the truth here. But this is today's public service announcement: Jewelers should watch what they say about the competition, because they may have to defend those comments in court.

And for a larger point: What does all this bashing do to consumer confidence and the overall perception of the industry?

Posted by Rob Bates on February 29, 2008 | Comments (4)

February 29, 2008
In response to: When Jewelers Bash Each Other
Mall Jewelry Boy commented:

I've said it before and I'll say it again: People need to be NICER! Stop dragging other jewelry retailers into the mud, whether it's Blue Nile, Zales, or Jared. You're only making yourself look petty. True competition is proving that you're better, not trying to knock the big players off their pedestal. When was the last time you saw Tiffany compare their prices to anyone else? And Rob's "larger point" is right on target. Jewelry retailers have a horrible reputation over price, quality, and service. If you tell a customer "Zales has bad quality, mine is better and costs less!", they might not believe you. If you SHOW a customer how your quality is better, and instead can say, with confidence: "Zales has beautiful diamonds, but look at this diamond. I'm very selective about my diamonds, but this one just took my breath away!" Do unto others...right?

February 29, 2008
In response to: When Jewelers Bash Each Other
Jennifer Heebner commented:

Amen to "do unto others." People are not nice to each other.

March 3, 2008
In response to: When Jewelers Bash Each Other
Reuben Tom Kee commented:

Right on! Competition is healthy and should be conducted in a healthy not filthy manner! And jewelers should not shy away from saying hello to each other at social events...unless of course one is feeling guilty of badmouthin!!

March 5, 2008
In response to: When Jewelers Bash Each Other
Linda Rockman commented:

Bad mouthing a jewlers gems is not the way to go. They are only making them look small and unprofessional, which we should question their products and ethics.