Will Mine Safety Be a Consumer Issue? - Cutting Remarks

JCK Online

Cutting Remarks

Blog

Cutting Remarks

« "Tis the Season? (And Wal... | Main | Diamond Shavings: Your Friday ... »

Link This | Email this | Blog This | Comments (1)

Rob Bates

Will Mine Safety Be a Consumer Issue?
November 29, 2007

This is really an excellent post at Solitare about South Africa's mine sector, its dismal safety record, and the risk of a consumer backlash.

Diamond mining does not have a bad reputation safety-wise, but, as you can see in the chart printed on the Solitare post, the record of gold and platinum mines is atrocious. As the post notes, things have gotten so bad, the union in South Africa has called a one-day strike because so many miners are dying.

This risk of a backlash is very real. I recently got this email from a friend who didn't want to buy a diamond after watching -- believe it or not -- Ice Road Truckers:

I was watching a fascinating show on History Channel about what goes into transporting equipment to the diamond minds in the Arctic...people risking their lives for a stupid diamond...makes me want to give back my wedding rings. I'll definitely consider buying jewelry without precious stones, as it seems a lot of people suffer for it.

Because of Blood Diamond and all the rest, many consumers now think of diamond mining as inherently sleazy. I can't tell you how many times, when I tell people what I do, I am asked about how horrible things are in the diamond mines. When the story about the trapped South African gold miners was all over the news, I recall thinking, if that was a diamond mine, we'd be in a lot of trouble. Truly, this industry doesn't have room for error anymore.

Anyway, on the subject of social issues, Chaim also has a great column this week about the challenge of reforming the Sierra Leone diamond sector.

Posted by Rob Bates on November 29, 2007 | Comments (1)

December 3, 2007
In response to: Will Mine Safety Be a Consumer Issue?
G.T. KELLEY commented:

DeBeers are masters at economic governance. In that, they exert pressure in ways that astound us mere mortals. The ability to settle anti-trust suits in the US, and still remain a healthy cartel is nothing short of a miracle. Yet, when the Blood Diamonds campaign came into existence, the industry just hoped that this would pass without much attention being paid to it. Blood diamonds has soiled the glimmer of diamonds in some of the consuming public’s minds. Again, human rights activist have learned, that if they attack legitimate businesses down the pipeline, action will be exerted by its members. Although a little too late within our industry. Believing as I do, that DeBeers has the best collection of cleaver minds, put these people to the task of getting ahead of the surging problem. That is the only way our industry will escape another Blood Diamond massacre!