You are here

GIA Developing System to Evaluate Fancy Cuts

GIA Developing System to Evaluate Fancy Cuts

The Gemological Institute of America is developing a system to evaluate the cut of fancy-shaped diamonds, GIA distinguished research fellow James Shigley tells JCK.

“We want to determine what constitutes a good fancy cut and what doesn’t,” Shigley says. “What is an acceptable shape for a pear, or an oval, or a marquise?”

To that end, GIA conducted a series of observation tests at the most recent GemFair in Tucson, gauging attendees’ reactions to different types of marquise, oval, and pear shapes. Any evaluation system will likely be a mixture of both mathematical calculations and observational tests, which is how the GIA developed its round brilliant cut grade, Shigley says.

Even so, Shigley isn’t sure the lab will devise a grading system for fancies.

“I’m not certain we will end up with a grade,” he says. “We just don’t know that yet. We are doing our due diligence.”

He adds that the GIA will look to the trade for input, and “recognizes there is a lot of experimentation [with fancy cuts].”

Wherever the system ends up, Shigley says the GIA doesn’t want to take a decade to finish its research, as it did with its round brilliant cut grade.

“We want a much shorter timeline,” he says.

Register For


Sunday, July 24 - Tuesday, July 26, 2016

Register Today!
Subscribe now to

JCK News Daily

Receive the latest news directly to your inbox

This will be an interesting case to follow

Its about time that some one takes one of the Whore Manufactures to...

Hey everyone. We have just gotten a bunch of anti-John Hardy comments...

Thank you Rob for your excellent article on the new credit card...

nice blogs very informative, greetings from Melemarie